Carla J Easton - I Think That I Might Love You

Throughout the process of making her acclaimed documentary Since Yesterday: The Untold Story of Scotland's Girl Bands, women kept telling Carla J Easton how they bought a guitar, learnt three chords, and dived headfirst into making music. Having built her career around playing keys – through four solo albums, her band’s TeentCanteen and Poster Paints, and currently as part of The Vaselines live setup – she couldn’t shake this idea of following where so many of her heroes had led. 

That seed of an idea soon became the basis for I Think That I Might Love You, Carla’s fifth solo album – still a pop album at heart, but also her first ‘guitar’ record. Produced by Howard Bilerman (Godspeed You! Black Emperor, Wolf Parade, Leonard Cohen, The Weather Station) the album finds Carla gathering up friends old and new to craft a record that feels like a natural but also significant leap forward. 

The new album was inspired not only by her time making the Since Yesterday film, but also by her work within Hen Hoose, the Scottish songwriting collective that unites a diverse array of female and non-binary artists, writers and producers to create new work collaboratively. As such, I Think That I Might Love You includes a number of co-writes across its eleven new songs, including Simon Liddell (Frightened Rabbit, Poster Paints), Hen Hoose’s MALKA (Hen Hoose), Glasgow’s Man of the Minch, Canadian singer songwriter Brett Nelson, and cult hero Darren Hayman of Hefner. 

Recorded live off the floor at Glasgow’s legendary Chem 19 studio – and with just a single day’s rehearsal – I Think That I Might Love You is a spirited expression of communal energy; an old school approach to a bold new chapter, a vivid capturing of human performance.

It is also, both suitably and understandably, an album about friendship – a celebration of such things but also a reflection on what it means to lose them. Indeed, the album’s path began in a recording booth at Third Man Records in Nashville, Carla side by side with her friend and songwriting companion Brett Nelson. “We started writing about this idea of the red thread, the red string of fate,” Carla explains. “It’s the idea that you have more than one soulmate, platonic as well as romantic. You’re usually only going to meet people in your postcode, but with billions of people on the planet you've probably got soulmates all over the world. So if you find any kind of thread, that's something really important and you should pick it up and follow it.”

Lead single ‘Oh Yeah’ is also the album’s glowing opener, setting things off with a bucketload of warmth. Co-written with her Poster Paints bandmate Simon Liddell, it’s animated and full of spirit, the track wrapped-up within two-minutes, flying along in a heady rush of melodrama, all glowing melodies and a dizzying sense of adventure. 

Then there’s ‘Let’s Make Plans For The Weekend’ – a co-write with Pedro Cameron – which buzzes in an appropriately colourful style. A buoyant and sharp three-minute pop song, Carla’s voice is spirited and jubilant as the song bursts forward, characteristically infectious, an undercurrent of restless energy. While ‘Red Kites In the Sun’ is classic Scottish indie-pop. Something of a slow-build, it opens with jangly guitars front-and-centre, before the instrumentation shines and swells around her, the song opening up into a warm-hearted gem, the wistful strings adding a whole heap of romanticism that feels deeply charming. 

Elsewhere, ‘Really, Really, Really, Really Sad’, written with with Darren Hayman is swooning and decadent, a 60s tinged burst of heavy-hearted pop, while  ‘Pillars Crash Down’, written with Brett Nelson on a vintage 60s organ, feels like the moment the album’s many shades come together; the heavy-hearted nature of the album’s more withdrawn moments finding a balance with its exuberance, to showcase what feels like a bold new chapter in Carla’s ever-shifting story. 

“When you're co-writing you can find yourself working with genres or sounds that you don't normally do,” Carla says, reflecting on the process. “And that’s great, because I like to keep learning. At this stage, I'm not really trying to reinvent the wheel, I'm here to have fun.”

If that sounds somewhat flippant it’s not supposed to. Carla’s songwriting has changed and improved over the years, and that growth has led her to approach the new album with a whole new dose of confidence. I Think That I Might Love You thrives within that approach, swept up in glistening immediacy, paying no mind to over-thinking. “There’s a shared euphoria that comes from finishing a song you’ve been co-writing with someone,” Carla says. “That’s the feeling we were trying to capture here.”

It’s captured in songs that stirred from a similar place to those women mentioned above, the ones who picked up a guitar, taught themselves to play it, and dived headfirst into spaces they haven’t always been invited to. Those songs grew from long road-trips through the States, through shared voice-notes from her home to friends near and far, and finally on to the Glasgow studio where the whole album came so vibrantly to life. As such, I Think That I Might Love You is a record of communal heart and power. That’s the thread that was followed, and it’s what runs right through these songs from start to finish, binding them all together. Cherry-red and glowing with life.  (Tom Johnson)